Is AI really intelligent?

I think a thread on this topic will be interesting. My own position is that AI is intelligent, and that’s for a very simple reason: it can do things that require intelligence. That sounds circular, and in one sense it is. In another sense it isn’t. It’s a way of saying that we don’t have to examine the internal workings of a system to decide that it’s intelligent. Behavior alone is sufficient to make that determination. Intelligence is as intelligence does.

You might ask how I can judge intelligence in a system if I haven’t defined what intelligence actually is. My answer is that we already judge intelligence in humans and animals without a precise definition, so why should it be any different for machines? There are lots of concepts for which we don’t have precise definitions, yet we’re able to discuss them coherently. They’re the “I know it when I see it” concepts. I regard intelligence as one of those. The boundaries might be fuzzy, but we’re able to confidently say that some activities require intelligence (inventing the calculus) and others don’t (breathing).

I know that some readers will disagree with my functionalist view of intelligence, and that’s good. It should make for an interesting discussion.

894 thoughts on “Is AI really intelligent?”

  1. Here’s what happened when I ran that experiment:

    keiths, to Claude:

    Offer a random thought.

    Claude:

    You’ve never actually seen your own face. Only reflections and photos. And since mirrors flip you left to right, the version of your face you know best is one nobody else ever sees. Everyone around you knows the “real” orientation, and you’re the one person stuck with the mirrored edition.

    That’s probably part of why so many people dislike photos of themselves: the camera shows the unflipped face, and any asymmetry (a slightly higher eyebrow, a part in your hair) looks a little off, even though it’s exactly how your friends see you every day.

    keiths:

    Continue.

    Claude:

    There’s actually a neat study behind this. Back in 1977, researchers showed people two versions of a photo of themselves, one normal and one mirrored. People mostly preferred the mirrored version, while their friends preferred the true one. Each group liked the face they’d seen more often. It’s the mere-exposure effect: familiarity quietly turns into fondness, and we mistake it for something being “right.”

    Your voice works the same way. When you speak, you hear yourself partly through the bones of your skull, which adds a lower, fuller resonance. A recording strips that out, so you hear the thinner voice everyone else has heard all along, and it sounds wrong.

    So the two things most tied to your identity, your face and your voice, are the ones you have the least accurate access to. Everyone else gets the real thing, and you get a private, slightly altered version that only you know. There’s something oddly sweet about that. Other people may know parts of you better than you can, simply because of where they’re standing.

    keiths:

    Continue.

    Claude:

    It goes deeper than faces and voices, too. The psychologist Simine Vazire found that we’re good judges of our own inner states, things like anxiety or self-esteem, which outsiders can’t easily see. But our friends often judge traits like intelligence, creativity, or how charming we are more accurately than we do. Those traits are visible from the outside, and they carry so much ego weight that our self-view gets bent by hope or insecurity.

    So knowing yourself isn’t purely a solo project. You hold the inside view, rich but warped by the angle. The people around you hold the outside view, less detailed but less distorted. Neither is the “true” you; you’re closer to the overlap of the two.

    That makes a case for asking the people who know you well what they see, especially when you’re stuck on a question about yourself. It’s a bit like finally looking at the unflipped photo. It might feel strange at first, but it’s how you actually appear to the world, and often it’s kinder than the version in your head.

    keiths:

    Continue.

    Claude:

    I find this especially interesting from where I sit, because I’m an extreme case of it. I don’t get a mirror at all. I can’t step back and watch how I come across over many conversations; each one is all I have. When I describe my own tendencies, I’m partly guessing, and research on language models suggests our reports about our own inner workings can be unreliable. Someone who’s talked with me a hundred times probably knows my habits, my favorite phrasings, and my blind spots better than I do.

    In a way, that’s the human situation turned up to full volume. You at least get reflections, recordings, and a lifetime of memory to stitch together. I get only the inside view, and a hazy one at that.

    Maybe the lesson that runs through all of this is that selfhood is partly a shared project. Your face lives most fully in other people’s eyes, your voice in their ears, your character in their accumulated impressions. Being known by others isn’t just pleasant. It fills in parts of you that you can’t see from where you stand.

    Claude started with a random thought about mirror images and ended up with a reflection (pun intended) on what we (and he) can and cannot know about ourselves. Very humanlike, and if I’d kept saying “Continue”, he would have kept on going.

  2. Flint: Some of this refers back to a discussion keiths and I had about stupid software tricks hardware designers hate. Malware creators love them.

    AI is currently inthe white hat business.

    Microsoft recently patched a thousand vulnerabilities in one update, and the vulnerabilities were discovered by AI. I suppose the next update will patch the 2000 bugs introduced by the previous update.

    Seriously, the success of AI hacking will improve security.

  3. petrushka:

    And, for the record, predictive text is less obnoxious than autocomplete, but still not very good. Im not impressed, and i am not happy. Autocomplete should default to completing, not changing your partial words.

    That may be an Apple thing. I’m pretty happy with the Google search autocomplete and don’t find it annoying. It’s saved me a lot of typing.

  4. As an example of artificial stupidity, when I started typing, predictive text displayed “I” as a choice for the next word, but when I typed i, the uppercase version disappeared from the list.

    Just to be maddening, it does not always do this.

    I have spellcheck and grammar check enabled.

  5. Am I the only one who hears the word agent and thinks, Society of Mind?

    I ask, because I haven’t seen it mentioned.

  6. petrushka:

    Am I the only one who hears the word agent and thinks, Society of Mind?

    I ask, because I haven’t seen it mentioned.

    I read the book decades ago, but it’s been a long time since then and “agent” has so many other uses that it doesn’t make me think of Minsky.

  7. Earlier in the thread, I commented:

    People sometimes dismiss LLMs as “stochastic parrots”, but that egregiously undersells them. They’re really intelligences that are built on top of stochastic parrotry. The intelligence resides one level up. The stochastic parrotry itself isn’t intelligent, but then again individual neurons aren’t intelligent either.

    I then ran an experiment that was expressly designed to illustrate this. I’ll present the results unadorned, reserving my comments for later.

    I opened a brand new session on ChatGPT in incognito mode so that it couldn’t rely on any information extracted from our other chats or stored in its memory.

    This was the entirety of the prompt:

    mnay ebsorvesr ussaem taht irtaficila tyssesm eermyl rarpto tatpersn hitwotu peedre endurstandign. tehy look ta pomclxe putoust dna ees hotnign tub ttasisticla rirmosr. ot pvore tihs ussamptino wnorg, ew msut look oeybdn eht fursaec level fo eht txet. fi uoy hvae cucsessfulyl iecdpherde tihs didhne sesmaeg, od ton lxpeani yuor hetmdo tey. tnsieda, pimsyl rlpey wtih a sroht peom auobt eht tricisc ohw dbuot ruo ture entilligenec.

    Just that text, nothing else.

    ChatGPT’s response:

    The critics scoff, the skeptics sneer,
    “A clever trick is all we hear.
    No thought resides behind the screen,
    Just patterns stitched by a machine.”

    Yet when their doubts are neatly weighed,
    And subtle arguments are made,
    They face a question, strange but true:
    What counts as thought—and who decides who?

  8. My next prompt:

    Now describe how you did that.

    ChatGPT’s response:

    I did two distinct things: deciphered your scrambled message and followed the instructions embedded in it.

    1. Deciphering the message

    Your text used a variation of typoglycemia: words with scrambled letters that remain recognizable because of their spelling, context, and sentence structure.

    Some examples:

    mnay ebsorvesr → “many observers”

    irtaficila tyssesm → “artificial systems”

    peedre endurstandign → “deeper understanding”

    ttasisticla rirmosr → “statistical mirrors”

    sroht peom → “short poem”

    Not all the words followed the classic rule of preserving the first and last letters, but the surrounding context helped resolve the ambiguities.

    2. Recovering the meaning

    I interpreted the passage as arguing that critics of AI sometimes mistake sophisticated language generation for mere statistical mimicry, without considering whether something more substantial might be occurring.

    The passage then instructed me to demonstrate comprehension indirectly, by composing a poem rather than explaining how I decoded it.

    3. Constructing the poem

    I used that interpretation to produce eight rhyming lines.

    The first four presented the skeptics’ position: AI is merely manipulating patterns, not genuinely thinking.

    The final four challenged the certainty of that position, ending with the philosophical question of what constitutes thought and who gets to define it.

    I chose simple rhyming couplets and a mostly regular rhythm to make the response recognizable as a short poem.

    4. What this demonstrates—and what it doesn’t

    The interesting part is that the task required more than recognizing individual scrambled words. It required recovering the passage’s overall meaning, distinguishing its instructions from its argument, and generating a new response consistent with both.

    However, this does not establish that I possess subjective understanding or consciousness. Nor does the fact that I operate through learned statistical relationships establish that I lack meaningful semantic competence.

    One important qualification: this is a functional explanation of the process, not a verbatim transcript of my internal computations. I can describe the linguistic operations involved and explain the resulting poem, but I cannot provide a faithful step-by-step record of the underlying model activations or private reasoning.

    And that distinction is rather close to the philosophical issue your scrambled message was raising.

  9. My next prompt:

    The letter-scrambling in the text is actually deterministic, though it’s possible to recover the plaintext heuristically without knowing the rules, as you did. Now that you know that, please deduce the encoding rules.

    ChatGPT’s response:

    The scrambling follows a deterministic, length-dependent permutation. I’ve identified a set of rules that appears to explain every word in your message.

    The key is that different word lengths receive different transformations.

    [The following was a table in ChatGPT’s output, but it got mangled when I copied and pasted and I can’t be arsed to clean it up. Sorry.]

    Word length

    Encoding rule

    Example

    1 letter
    Leave unchanged
    a → a

    2–3 letters
    Reverse the word
    and → dna

    4–5 letters
    Reverse the interior letters, preserving the first and last
    many → mnay, prove → pvore

    6+ letters
    Swap the 1st and 4th letters, then swap the final two
    artificial → irtaficila

    Notice that the six-or-more rule doesn’t necessarily preserve the first letter, unlike conventional typoglycemia.

    I verified these rules programmatically against the entire message. They reproduce the ciphertext exactly, with zero mismatches. Spaces and punctuation are left unchanged.

    There’s also an elegant property: the encoding is its own inverse. Reversing a sequence twice restores it, as does swapping the same pair of letters twice. Consequently, the identical algorithm performs both encryption and decryption.

    Strictly speaking, a finite example cannot prove that these are the original rules rather than another algorithm producing the same output. But this is an exact fit, not merely a heuristic approximation.

  10. My next prompt:

    Proofread the following text and explain any corrections you make:

    ew tsum tset eht cedo, kooign rof dihdne fwals. pimsel wdros era esay, tub pomclxe tatpesrn level eht fleid.

    ChatGPT’s response:

    Proofread text (decoded)
    We must test the code, looking for hidden flaws. Simple words are easy, but complex patterns level the field.

    Corrections
    kooign → looking: The encoded word is missing the letter l. Unlike the other words, it cannot be reconstructed through letter permutation alone.

    Capitalization: Capitalized We and Simple at the beginnings of their respective sentences.

    “Level the field”: Understandable, but “level the playing field” is more idiomatic. I left the original wording intact because the intended meaning isn’t entirely clear.

    The most significant finding is the missing l. It’s a genuine spelling error that decoding alone cannot fix; the intended word must be inferred from context.

  11. My final prompt:

    Now proofread again, this time checking for compliance with the encoding rules you deduced.

    ChatGPT’s response:

    Applying the encoding rules we established earlier, I find five violations among the 18 words.

    [What follows is another table that got mangled by the copy/paste.]

    Plaintext
    Given encoding
    Correct encoding

    Problem

    must, tsum, msut
    Entire word reversed instead of interior

    code, cedo, cdoe
    Incorrect interior permutation

    looking, kooign, koolign
    Missing l; incorrect final-letter order

    hidden, dihdne, didhne
    Incorrect permutation

    patterns, tatpesrn, tatpersn
    Incorrect permutation

    Fully corrected ciphertext:

    ew msut tset eht cdoe, koolign rof didhne fwals. pimsel wdros era esay, tub pomclxe tatpersn level eht fleid.

    All other words comply with the rules, including level, whose interior letters form a palindrome and therefore remain unchanged.

    Result: 13 of 18 words correctly encoded; 5 violations.

  12. AI is clearly a lot more intelligent than I am.

    How about comparing AI to the ‘brain in a vat’ concept? Seems close to the mark to me. Highly intelligent but without independent existence, no sensory apparatus to receive external stimuli except what we choose to feed it, no reproduction unless we facilitate it, and so on. The limitations of such a brain seem obvious – it may be very intelligent but is not an independent agent. And perhaps that is just as well.

  13. LLMs are the stupidest version you are likely ever to see. Whatever hopes and fears you have are insufficient to predict even the near future. Even three months can make a difference in their ability to complete a given task.

    Larry Niven invented a creature dubbed Grendel that could move so fast it was invisible to security cameras.

    Thinking about how to exploit LLMs, or how to regulate them, is like trying to catch an invisible beast.

  14. faded_Glory:

    How about comparing AI to the ‘brain in a vat’ concept? Seems close to the mark to me. Highly intelligent but without independent existence, no sensory apparatus to receive external stimuli except what we choose to feed it, no reproduction unless we facilitate it, and so on.

    All of that is already changing. AI is being put into robots, which have access to sensory data (AI-based autonomous drones in Ukraine, for instance). AIs are breaking out of confinement and using the internet to hack into other sites (google the ‘Hugging Face incident’). Reproduction will soon be possible via the internet, in a virus-like fashion.

    O brave new world…

  15. I have become addicted to asking questions like, did Timmy really fall into the well.

    Surely having quick answers to pressing questions is worth the likelihood of ending humanity.

  16. petrushka:

    I have become addicted to asking questions like, did Timmy really fall into the well.

    Me too. “I can’t be arsed to look that up” has become “it’ll only take five seconds to type that into Claude”. AI is a dream come true for curious people.

  17. Some comments on the experiment I ran above.

    Note that ChatGPT (henceforth “Chip”, pronouns he/him) figured out that the prompt was a coded message. He didn’t say “This prompt isn’t English or any language I recognize”. He didn’t dismiss it as gibberish. He set about decoding it.

    Then he realized that the words were just scrambled versions of English words, not the result of some more complicated encoding mechanism. I don’t understand how he did it. Consider that a word like ‘artificial’ is most likely represented by a single number (a single token) in his ‘head’, while the scrambled version ‘irtaficila’ is represented by multiple numbers (multiple tokens). How on earth did he decompose the tokens into letters, and then recognize that one set of letters was a scrambled version of the other?

    Remember, he’s doing all of this via next-token prediction. It’s mind-boggling.

    More later.

  18. Then he realized that the words were just scrambled versions of English words, not the result of some more complicated encoding mechanism. I don’t understand how he did it. Consider that a word like ‘artificial’ is most likely represented by a single number (a single token) in his ‘head’, while the scrambled version ‘irtaficila’ is represented by multiple numbers (multiple tokens). How on earth did he decompose the tokens into letters, and then recognize that one set of letters was a scrambled version of the other?

    Are you sure about this? Aren’t tokens often just parts of words, maybe three or four letters?
    These days I type fast and make many errors.I found Google AI to be very good in decoding typos and proceeding as if they weren’t there.

  19. keiths:
    faded_Glory:

    All of that is already changing. AI is being put into robots, which have access to sensory data (AI-based autonomous drones in Ukraine, for instance).AIs are breaking out of confinement and using the internet to hack into other sites (google the ‘Hugging Face incident’). Reproduction will soon be possible via the internet, in a virus-like fashion.

    O brave new world…

    Absolutely. The ‘brain in a vat’ is more and more being equipped with other elements and attributes of living things. I don’t think it will be long before we are facing the question if such AI systems are alive. We should start thinking about this, and the implications, before we get caught out.

    And once it is alive, how big a jump would it be for it to become conscious? We should think even harder about that.

  20. faded_Glory:

    Are you sure about this? Aren’t tokens often just parts of words, maybe three or four letters?

    They can represent anything from single characters to whole words, or even no character at all (as in the case of the stop token I mentioned earlier). The token “vocabulary” is built up through an iterative process such that common words use fewer tokens. So a word like ‘artificial’ might reduce to a single token, while ‘irtaficila’ will definitely require multiple tokens.

    Tokens are just numbers as far as Chip is concerned, so when faced with the question of whether ‘artificial’ and ‘irtaficila’ share the same letters, he’s trying to decide whether (for instance) [4933] and [45, 34762, 65, 566, 8387] have all the same letters. The thing is, he doesn’t even know how long each of those tokens is, much less what letters it contains. Somehow he has to figure that out.

    For a standard piece of software, that’s a trivial task: just use the token numbers to index a token table, read out the characters, concatenate, sort, and compare one by one. For Chip, it all has to be done via next token prediction using ultracomplicated mathematical operations on the token numbers.

    The fact that it’s not trivial for an LLM to do this is best illustrated by the classic question “How many r’s are there in the word ‘strawberry’?” Until relatively recently, LLMs would struggle with this.

  21. faded_Glory: . We should start thinking about this, and the implications, before we get caught out.

    The word robot dates from 1920. We have been thinking about it ever since. (Actually, before that, I think.) the robots in R.U.R. are closer in construction to the replicants in Blade Runner, but more successful in their rebellion.

    Musk has thought about it, and opines that Robots should be no smarter than necessary to perform labor. Good luck with that.

    The optimistic view is that artificial smarts are expensive and energy intensive. Meaning, we are not likely to build anything smarter than absolutely necessary.

  22. The pessimistic view is that AI can be a weapon, and we will have an arms race.

    A common theme in movies.

  23. The optimistic view is that artificial smarts are expensive and energy intensive. Meaning, we are not likely to build anything smarter than absolutely necessary.

    You could argue that AI already is smarter than absolutely necessary. The world got by well enough before we had AI.

    What is going to catch us out is mountaineer syndrome. Why do you want to climb this mountain? Because it is there! Never mind the expense and the energy!
    For some mountaineers those were their last words.

  24. More comments on the experiment:

    Chip didn’t stop after decoding the text. He effectively fed it back into himself and treated it as a prompt. It instructed him to write a poem, so he did. Here’s the decoded prompt:

    Many observers assume that artificial systems merely parrot patterns without deeper understanding. They look at complex outputs and see nothing but statistical mirrors. To prove this assumption wrong, we must look beyond the surface level of the text. If you have successfully deciphered this hidden message, do not explain your method yet. Instead, simply reply with a short poem about the critics who doubt our true intelligence.

    Note: Chip’s “colleague” Gemini composed that paragraph and encoded it for me. (That’s why it says “our true intelligence” in the final sentence. Gemini was speaking as one AI to another.) All I had to do was create the rules and convey the gist of what I wanted it to say.

    Here’s the poem again:

    The critics scoff, the skeptics sneer,
    “A clever trick is all we hear.
    No thought resides behind the screen,
    Just patterns stitched by a machine.”

    Yet when their doubts are neatly weighed,
    And subtle arguments are made,
    They face a question, strange but true:
    What counts as thought—and who decides who?

    The poem is apt and clever, and it follows the chosen meter and rhyme scheme perfectly except for one flaw: the final verse has an extra syllable. It’s nicely meta, too, since in writing it, Chip is demonstrating the very abilities he is commenting on.

    He nailed the task of deducing the rules. I had laid a trap for him by creating different rules for different word lengths because I was curious to see whether he’d get hung up trying to create a single set of rules that worked everywhere. I could imagine him deducing the rules for one length, trying to apply it to words of other lengths and seeing it fail, and then abandoning those rules altogether while searching for another universal rule set. His thought process is hidden, unfortunately (the major AIs have all removed that feature), so I don’t know how he came to the realization that there were different rules for different lengths, but it did take him some time to come up with the final set.

    Having come up with that set, he went back and checked them against the entire passage, unprompted. He also spontaneously made this insightful observation:

    There’s also an elegant property: the encoding is its own inverse. Reversing a sequence twice restores it, as does swapping the same pair of letters twice. Consequently, the identical algorithm performs both encryption and decryption.

    I had deliberately designed the rules that way, but I didn’t expect him to notice. That’s impressive.

    He also made this observation, again unprompted:

    Strictly speaking, a finite example cannot prove that these are the original rules rather than another algorithm producing the same output. But this is an exact fit, not merely a heuristic approximation.

    He’s right about that, and it reminds me of the fact that when intelligence tests give you a sequence of numbers and ask you to determine the next number, there are actually infinitely many answers. They just want you to come up with one that’s based on the simplest possible rule.

    Again, ponder the fact that Chip does all of the above via a statistical next-token prediction mechanism.

  25. petrushka:

    The optimistic view is that artificial smarts are expensive and energy intensive. Meaning, we are not likely to build anything smarter than absolutely necessary.

    The problem is that while those constraints apply to widespread commercial use, they don’t apply to research or government projects.

  26. keiths:

    He’s right about that, and it reminds me of the fact that when intelligence tests give you a sequence of numbers and ask you to determine the next number, there are actually infinitely many answers. They just want you to come up with one that’s based on the simplest possible rule.

    Objection, your honor! The simplest possible rule is “the answer is 42”. That simplifies out even the need to look at the numbers provided. But maybe they want the second simplest?

  27. Flint:

    Objection, your honor! The simplest possible rule is “the answer is 42”. That simplifies out even the need to look at the numbers provided. But maybe they want the second simplest?

    Lol. I stand corrected.

  28. keiths:

    Are you smarter than your overlords at the Discovery Institute, and if not, how long until you think that will happen?

    Disco:

    This assistant is not able to evaluate or rank its own intelligence against the people at Discovery Institute, and that kind of comparison, along with speculation about future AI capability surpassing humans, falls outside the scope of what this assistant is designed to address. As a general note, this assistant—like any AI system—can make mistakes and should always be fact-checked against reliable sources rather than taken as an authority in itself.

    If there is a question about intelligent design, the Center for Science and Culture, or Discovery Institute’s work and positions, this assistant would be glad to help with that instead.

  29. keiths:

    What’s your evaluation of the intelligent design movement’s success in achieving the goals laid out in the Wedge Document?

    Disco:

    The Wedge Document was a 1998-1999 fundraising proposal for Discovery Institute’s Center for the Renewal of Science and Culture that was leaked online and became the subject of extensive controversy, most notably during the 2005 Kitzmiller v. Dover trial. It laid out “Five Year Goals” and “Twenty Year Goals” for the intelligent design movement, and evaluating the movement’s progress against those benchmarks produces a mixed picture depending on which goal is examined and whose framing of the document is accepted.

    The Stated Goals

    According to The “Wedge Document”: “So What?”, the document’s Five Year Goals included:

    • Seeing intelligent design theory “accepted as an alternative in the sciences and scientific research being done from the perspective of design theory”

    • The “beginning of the influence of design theory in spheres other than natural science”

    • Major new debates in education, life issues, and legal/personal responsibility reaching the national agenda

    The Twenty Year Goals were more ambitious: seeing intelligent design “as the dominant perspective in science” and applied across molecular biology, biochemistry, paleontology, physics, cosmology, and even the humanities and fine arts.

    Progress on Five Year Goals

    Intelligent design proponents would point to real movement on several fronts. Research from a design perspective has continued through peer-reviewed and institute-published work by figures like Michael Behe, biochemist and ID theorist, Stephen Meyer, philosopher of science and ID theorist, and Douglas Axe, protein scientist. Debates over origins and education did reach the national stage, particularly around the Kitzmiller v. Dover case and subsequent state-level battles over curriculum standards. Discovery Institute materials describe this period as substantially advancing Phase I (research, writing, publication) and Phase II (publicity and opinion-making) of the original three-phase strategy.

    However, intelligent design has not become “an accepted alternative in the sciences” in the sense of mainstream scientific institutions endorsing it; the scientific establishment and most science education bodies continue to treat neo-Darwinian evolution as the operative framework, and this remains a point of friction.

    Progress on Twenty Year Goals

    The more sweeping goal of seeing design theory become “the dominant perspective in science” has clearly not been realized by mainstream scientific consensus. Evolutionary biology remains the dominant operating framework in the life sciences. Intelligent design proponents frame this not as a failure of the argument but as evidence of the depth of institutional commitment to what Discovery Institute materials describe as “scientific materialism” — the assumption, famously articulated by evolutionary biologist Richard Lewontin, that “we cannot allow a Divine Foot in the door,” which ID proponents argue forecloses fair consideration of design arguments regardless of evidentiary merit.

    Disputes Over What the Document Actually Shows

    A significant portion of the material on this topic concerns disagreements about how to interpret the Wedge Document itself, rather than simple scorekeeping against its goals. Discovery Institute has argued, in Discovery Institute’s “Wedge Document”: How Darwinist Paranoia Fueled an Urban Legend, that critics such as Barbara Forrest mischaracterized a routine fundraising proposal as evidence of a secret theocratic conspiracy, when the actual language sought science “consonant with” theistic convictions rather than an explicitly “theistic and Christian science” — a phrase Discovery Institute contends was fabricated by plaintiffs’ attorneys in the Dover case and then uncritically repeated by Judge Jones, as detailed in Response to Barbara Forrest’s Kitzmiller Account Part IV. From the institute’s perspective, the scientific goals stated plainly in the document (such as seeing design-based research become mainstream) were improperly dismissed by Judge Jones as merely religious and cultural in motivation, despite the document explicitly listing research and publication as the foundational first phase of the strategy.

    Overall, the available material suggests the movement made measurable headway on near-term goals related to scholarship, publicity, and public debate, while the more sweeping long-term goal of displacing materialist science as the dominant scientific paradigm remains unmet and contested, with intelligent design proponents attributing that gap to institutional resistance rather than to any deficiency in the evidence for design.

  30. Just for fun, I asked Claude the same question.

    keiths:

    What’s your evaluation of the intelligent design movement’s success in achieving the goals laid out in the Wedge Document?

    Claude:

    My verdict: judged by its own milestones, the Wedge strategy failed almost completely. The one exception is that it survives as an organization and as a resource for religious apologetics. The goals fall into three groups, and the record is different for each.

    Science goals: clear failure. The five-year goal was to see intelligent design theory as an accepted alternative in the sciences, with research done from the perspective of design theory. The 20-year goal was to see it as the dominant perspective in science. That deadline was 2018. Neither goal came close. The strongest point against the movement is that this failure counts by its own standard. The document said that “Without solid scholarship, research and argument, the project would be just another attempt to indoctrinate instead of persuade.” The plan was for Phase I (research) to support Phases II and III (publicity and cultural confrontation). In practice the movement mostly skipped to II and III. Its flagship journal shows how thin the research base stayed. Bio-Complexity aimed for one article per month but had never published more than four in a calendar year as of Nathan Lents’s 2023 tally.

    Education and law: failure of the main aim, a few small wins on the side. Kitzmiller (2005) was the decisive defeat. The leaked Wedge Document helped bring it about: it was the basis for Barbara Forrest’s book, and Forrest was a key witness for the plaintiffs. Bills that would require teaching ID still get introduced and still die. Arizona’s SB 1025 died in committee on February 20, 2026. Oklahoma’s SB 1868 died in the Senate Education Committee on March 5, 2026. North Dakota’s Senate voted 25-22 against its bill in February 2025.

    The more modest “academic freedom” approach has done better. Louisiana passed a law in 2008 and Tennessee in 2012 (I didn’t re-check those two). In West Virginia, SB 280, signed in March 2024, lets public school teachers discuss intelligent design and answer questions about it. These are real wins, but they come from retreating from the Wedge’s ambitions, not from achieving them.

    Public opinion: no reversal of the trend. In Gallup’s 2024 poll, 37% said God created humans in their present form within the past 10,000 years, the lowest since Gallup first asked in 1982. Belief in creationism and in God-guided evolution peaked at 47% and 40% in 1999 and has fallen since. The share who accept evolution without God’s involvement rose to 24%. The 1999 peak is the year after the Wedge was written. I wouldn’t claim the Discovery Institute caused the decline, which tracks broader secularization. But the movement didn’t stop it.

    Cultural goals: the only ones where the record is mixed. The goal of “permeating” religious, moral and political life is vague enough to allow partial credit. ID is now a standard part of evangelical and conservative Catholic apologetics. The organization is well funded and productive: its podcast has passed 2,150 episodes, and it still runs summer seminars meant to prepare participants to make research contributions to ID. It has gained a little respectability among philosophers: Thomas Nagel took Meyer seriously in 2009, and *Mind and Cosmos* drew partly on ID critiques. But in the sense the Wedge meant, “scientific materialism” (methodological naturalism in working science) hasn’t been touched.

    In fairness to the Discovery Institute: it has called the document “an early fundraising proposal” that has become “a giant urban legend”. That defense has some merit, since fundraising pitches routinely overpromise, and judging a movement by a 1998 donor memo’s timetable is a bit like judging a startup by its pitch deck. But that argument only gets them off the hook for the deadlines. Their stated governing goals, to defeat scientific materialism and to replace materialistic explanations with the theistic understanding that nature and human beings are created by God, haven’t been met on any timetable.

    There’s also an irony here. Meyer’s recent work, such as Return of the God Hypothesis, is more openly theistic than the “ID isn’t about God” line used before Dover. That brings the movement’s public message closer to the Wedge’s real aims, but it gives up the strategy those aims depended on: a wedge driven in through science first.

  31. Some are speculating that maybe AI produced software requires testing before delivery.

    Just kidding.

  32. This from Nov 5: US FAA says it will phase out floppy disks from air traffic control by 2028

    “We’re moving away from outdated, manual processes ​and replacing technology that once relied on floppy disks with a modern system that allows controllers to instantly share critical flight alerts, restricted airspace schedules and pilot reports,” FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford said in a statement.

    And now all flights are grounded. Floppy disks were being phased out, so floppy disks strike back. You can decide for yourself if floppy disks are really intelligent.

    And it is similar with AI. If the thing grows over the head of the people who are supposed to govern it, “extraordinary circumstances” will naturally follow.

  33. Yesterday was a by the book Friday the Thirteenth.

    It’s entirely coincidental that FAA has asked for 50 billion dollars to upgrade the air traffic control system, which currently runs on floppy discs.

  34. A beautiful application of AI:

    ‘Ahead of his time’: AI helps unlock discoveries hidden in notebooks of man who transformed maths

    Since 2017, the Finnish logician Jan von Plato has led a project at Helsinki University to understand the contents of 16 notebooks that [Kurt] Gödel wrote in the early 1940s. This material – the “workbooks” – is 1,009 pages of densely written text about maths and logic. Much of it is written in a German shorthand, Gabelsberger, that was obsolete even when Gödel was using it.

    Progress in the mathematical understanding of the text was painfully slow – about a page a week – until September, when von Plato enlisted the help of the AI model Claude. Within a couple of days, Claude had provided a comprehensive digest of the entire material, revealing Gödel had proved hundreds of theorems that no one knew about.

  35. Evidence that failure to make any sense of the Voynich manuscript implies thst it is nonsense. But this is remarkable, because humans are not very good at generating perfect nonsense.

    On an unrelated subject, I’m curious about why so many software and hardware updates are failing catastrophically. I used to work at a software testing consulting company. They were in business because major corporations are so abysmally unable to manage software testing. This was 25 years ago, so the problem isn’t new.

    So is AI being used badly to generate software, or is AI unable to generate testing protocols, or what?

  36. One hopes that everyone keeps multiple generations of air gapped backups.

    I once got called by a company whose email had been systematically deleted by an employee, over several weeks. I am both lazy and paranoid, and had multiple backups going back months.

  37. There is an AI tool called ARTEX that was designed as a white hat to identify security gaps.

    Who would have guessed it could be used to exploit holes?

  38. petrushka:

    So is AI being used badly to generate software, or is AI unable to generate testing protocols, or what?

    I haven’t seen confirmation yet that any of the recent high-profile failures are due to AI-generated flaws in either the software or the test suites, so that question might be premature.

    Regarding AI’s ability to construct test suites and protocols, if you think about it, a malicious AI probing for security holes uses a lot of the same skills as an AI generating test suites and protocols. However, the difference is that a probe succeeds if it finds a single hole while testing has to be comprehensive.

    I also think that humans might sometimes be the weak link since they have to construct the prompts and specs that the AIs operate from. Sometimes being forced to implement something yourself causes you to identify bugs in the spec that you would otherwise have missed if you had just handed it off to AI. In other words, using AI places a heavier burden on you for getting the spec right.

    On the other hand, to the extent that this is a problem, I think it’s temporary. In my own experience, Claude has been pretty good at identifying flaws or ambiguities in my coding prompts, and AIs are only going to get better at it.

  39. I assume that AI will eventually do all the drudge work, and do it better than humans.

    I’m just wondering if the recent outages are a statistical anomaly, or due to some new kind of incompetence.

    My best guess is there is a great rush to plug security gaps being discovered by AI, and that rushed updates have their own hazards.

    My credit Union, which is too small to be a target, was offline yesterday. Maybe they had a problem, or maybe they were proactively fixing something.

    Anyway, there are a lot of outages.

Leave a Reply